If you’re building your everyday carry (EDC) setup, you’ve probably faced this decision:
Should I carry a knife or a multitool?
Both are staples in the world of preparedness, self-reliance, and tactical readiness. But which one is better suited to your daily needs—or your bug-out philosophy?
In this guide, we break down the real-world use cases, pros and cons, and the best products available in 2025. No fluff. No gimmicks. Just clear guidance to help you build the loadout that works.
Knives vs. Multitools: What’s the Difference?
- EDC Knives are fast, lightweight, and purpose-built for cutting. They’re often stronger, easier to deploy, and more ergonomic than the blades on multitools.
- Multitools offer versatility—pliers, screwdrivers, can openers, saws—but their blades are usually secondary in quality and access.
Pros & Cons Breakdown
| Feature | EDC Knife | Multitool |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Use | Cutting, slicing | Utility, repairs, versatility |
| Blade Quality | Often superior (steel & grind) | Usually secondary, less ergonomic |
| Weight | Lightweight | Heavier |
| Deployment | One-hand open, fast | Slower, multi-step access |
| Functions | Single-purpose | Multiple tools in one |
| Cost Range | Mid-high for quality blades | Mid for quality multitools |
Use-Case Examples
- Urban EDC: Slim knife or multitool for box cutting, quick fixes, basic carry.
- Outdoor Survival: Multitool with saw, pliers, or firestarter shines.
- Tactical Loadout: Dedicated knife for speed and defense, multitool in secondary pouch.
- Minimalist Carry: Swiss Army–style compact multitool or ultra-light knife.
Recommended Products (2025 Picks)
All products below are from trusted brands and available through common affiliate programs like Amazon, OpticsPlanet, and others.
EDC Knife Picks
1. Spyderco Delica 4
- VG-10 steel blade
- Ultra-lightweight FRN handle
- One-hand opening with signature Spyderco thumb hole
- Compact yet capable — one of the most carried knives in EDC history.
2. Benchmade 533 Mini Bugout
- Ultralight (1.5 oz), premium CPM-S30V blade
- AXIS® locking mechanism
- Built for lightweight carry and hard use
- Made in USA with lifetime sharpening and warranty.
3. Cold Steel Recon 1 MagnaCut
- High-performance MagnaCut steel
- G10 handle scales
- Tactical-grade toughness
- For those who want a folder that feels like a fixed blade.
Multitool Picks
1. Leatherman Bond
- 14 essential tools
- Stainless steel, pocket-clip compatible
- Lightweight & sleek—great for urban or professional EDC
- Covered by Leatherman’s 25-year warranty.
2. Leatherman Signal
- Designed for survival and outdoor scenarios
- Includes fire starter, emergency whistle, and hammer
- 19 tools in total
- Great companion for bug-out or camp use.
3. Gerber Suspension-NXT
- Spring-loaded pliers, 15 tools
- Affordable, sturdy, and reliable
- Slim enough for pocket carry
- Popular entry-level multitool that punches above its price.
Hybrid Pick
4. Victorinox Classic SD Swiss Army Knife
- Blade, file, scissors, tweezers, and more
- TSA-friendly in some versions
- Great backup or ultra-light EDC
- Iconic, minimalist multitool for your keychain or wallet.
Which Should You Carry?
It depends on your goals:
| Priority | Go With… |
|---|---|
| Cutting efficiency | Benchmade Mini Bugout or Spyderco Delica |
| Overall utility | Leatherman Bond or Gerber Suspension |
| Outdoor survival | Leatherman Signal |
| Budget EDC | Victorinox Classic SD |
| Tactical use | Cold Steel Recon 1 |
Final Thoughts
The best EDC tool is the one that works for your environment. If you need simplicity and fast blade access, go knife. If versatility is key, go multitool. If space allows, carry both.
Still building your setup? Check out our other essential guides:
- 👉 Top 5 Tactical Flashlights for Home Defense (2025)
- 👉 Bug Out Bag Essentials: 10 Items That Actually Matter
Tactical Gear Source 
Leave a comment